top of page

High Stakes of Hiring - How to Interview Management Candidates Guide

High Stakes of Hiring - How to Interview Management Candidates Guide

The High Stakes of Hiring Excellence

In the dynamic landscape of business, every hiring decision carries significant weight, shaping the trajectory of a company. The stakes are high, and the consequences of a misjudged recruitment process can be financially staggering. Thats why the fakes here at Bigger Fish have created the "How to Interview Management Candidates Guide" to help you with your next interview.

Studies reveal that a substantial 74% of companies have admitted to the costly mistake of hiring the wrong person. Whatever the reasons for offering a job to the wrong person, it can turn out to be an expensive error. The CIPD estimates that a bad hire costs a business an average of £8,200 (that figure rises to £12,000 for senior managers or directors).

Beyond mere financial implications, a misaligned hire can disrupt team dynamics, hinder productivity, and impact overall organizational success. The broader financial impact extends from recruitment expenses to ongoing compensation and retention-related costs, ranging from £13,500 to a staggering £190,000 per bad hire. This underscores the paramount importance of meticulous and strategic hiring practices.

This comprehensive How to Interview Management Candidates Guide aims to equip interviewers with the tools and strategies needed to navigate the interview process effectively, ensuring that each hiring decision aligns with the company's goals and values while minimising the potential risks and costs associated with a suboptimal selection.

How to Interview Management Candidates - Planning the Session:

1. Introduction (10 minutes):

  • Welcome and Setting the Tone: Begin by welcoming the candidate and highlighting the critical role the management position plays in the organisation's success.

  • Overview of the Company and Role: Provide a brief introduction to your company's mission, values, and culture, emphasising the significance of the role within the broader organisational context.

2. Candidate Introduction (15 minutes):

  • Professional Background: Allow the candidate to walk you through their professional journey, emphasising significant achievements, roles, and responsibilities.

  • Leadership Philosophy: Encourage the candidate to share their leadership philosophy and how they approach managing teams and driving results.

3. Job and Company Overview (15 minutes):

  • Detailed Role Discussion: Dive deeper into the specifics of the management role. Discuss how the role contributes to the overall success of the company.

  • Team Structure and Dynamics: Explain the current team structure, dynamics, and the role's integration into the broader organisational context.

4. Behavioural and Situational Questions (50 - 60 minutes):

a. Leadership Style:

  • "Can you describe a specific situation where your leadership style positively influenced the team's performance?"

  • "How do you adapt your leadership approach to different team members and situations?"

b. Problem Solving:

  • "Describe a time when you had to make a tough decision under pressure. How did you approach it?"

  • "Share an example of a complex problem your team faced. What steps did you take to address it?"

c. Decision-Making:

  • "How do you balance making quick decisions with ensuring they are well-informed and strategic?"

  • "Share an instance when you had to make a decision that wasn't popular. How did you handle it?"

d. Team Development:

  • "How do you identify and nurture talent within your team to ensure long-term success?"

  • "Describe a situation where you had to address a team member's underperformance. What steps did you take?"

e. Communication Skills:

  • "Can you provide an example of a time when effective communication played a crucial role in achieving a team goal?"

  • "How do you stay in contact with your team members?"

f. Performance Management:

  • "What strategies do you employ for setting performance expectations and goals for your team?"

  • "What's your plan for building rapport and credibility with your new team?"

g. Additional Insight Questions:

  • "What was the best day at work you’ve had in the past three months?"

  • "What was the worst day you’ve had at work in the past three months?"

5. Using an Interview Scorecard (10 minutes):

  • Establish Criteria: Clearly define the key competencies and skills required for the management role. This may include leadership, decision-making, communication, and team development.

  • Scoring System: Develop a numerical scoring system (e.g., 1-5) for each competency. Ensure that all interviewers use the same scale to maintain consistency.

  • Behavioral Anchors: Create behavioral anchors for each score to guide interviewers in assigning ratings based on observable behaviors.

  • Collaborative Evaluation: If multiple interviewers are involved, encourage collaboration in the assessment process. Discuss scores and observations to ensure a holistic evaluation.

Additional Tips:

  • Note-Taking and Documentation: Keep detailed notes during the interview, documenting specific examples and behavioral indicators that align with the established criteria.

  • Adaptability: Be flexible in your questioning based on the candidate's responses. Follow up on interesting points to gain deeper insights.

  • Cultural Fit: Assess the candidate's alignment with your company's values and culture. Ask questions that reveal their understanding of and contribution to your organisation's ethos.

  • Candidate Engagement: Keep the candidate engaged throughout the interview by actively listening, providing feedback, and fostering a conversational atmosphere.

Candidate Questions and Closing (15 minutes):

  • Candidate Questions: Allow the candidate to ask questions about the role, team, and company culture. Pay attention to the nature and depth of their inquiries.

  • Next Steps: Provide information about the next steps in the hiring process, including any additional interviews or assessments.

  • Express Appreciation: Thank the candidate for their time and express enthusiasm about the potential collaboration.

Post-Interview Evaluation:

  • Consolidate Scores: After the interview, gather feedback from all interviewers and consolidate scores based on the interview scorecard.

  • Debrief Meeting: If multiple interviewers are involved, conduct a debrief meeting to discuss individual assessments, share observations, and arrive at a collective evaluation.

  • Candidate Comparison: Compare the scores and observations of each candidate to make informed decisions about their suitability for the management role.

By incorporating these elements into your management candidate interview process, you can ensure a thorough and fair assessment that goes beyond surface-level qualifications. The interview scorecard serves as a valuable tool for maintaining consistency and objectivity, making the hiring decision more data-driven and aligned with the needs of your organisation, ultimately minimising the potential risks and costs associated with a suboptimal selection.


bottom of page